The Outcomes View allows users to access program evaluation data from various industry reports and peer-reviewed sources for advanced primary care and medical home initiatives included on the Primary Care Innovations and PCMH Map. Click the buttons labeled “Industry Reports” and “Peer-reviewed Studies” for additional research and evidence on innovative primary care delivery models. Please contact pcmhmap@pcpcc.net if you have any additional program evaluation or outcomes data that should be included in the PCPCC map."
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
VA Health Services Research & Development (February 2019)In 2012, select Veterans Health Administration (VHA) facilities implemented a homeless-tailored medical home model, called Homeless Patient Aligned Care Teams (H-PACT), to improve care processes and outcomes for homeless Veterans.
American Journal of Managed Care (March 2015) During the study period from just prior to widespread PACT implementation to 2 years after PACT implementation began
Journal of Health Care Quality (November 2014) study evaluated PACT patients with post traumatic stress disorder using a pre/post study design
Health Affairs (June 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (July 2013)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (June 2015)
no statistically significant association between medical home implementation and improvements in 5 domains of patient care experiences
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (March 2015) During the study period from just prior to widespread PACT implementation to 2 years after PACT implementation began
Journal of Health Care Quality (November 2014) study evaluated PACT patients with post traumatic stress disorder using a pre/post study design
Health Services Research (August 2014)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
Health Affairs (June 2014)
Plos One (May 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (July 2013)
Health Affairs (June 2014)
The study found, "PACT was associated with modest increases in primary care visits and with modest decreases in both hospitalizations for ambulatory care–sensitive conditions and outpatient visits with mental health specialists. We found that these changes avoided $596 million in costs, compared to the investment in PACT of $774 million, for a potential net loss of $178 million in the study period. Although PACT has not generated a positive return, it is still maturing, and trends in costs and use are favorable. Adopting patient-centered care does not appear to have been a major financial risk for the VHA."
Now available in 18 regions.
Now available in 18 regions
Montana Medicaid has approximately 45,500 members attributed to CPC+ providers. The Medicaid expansion (HELP) and Healthy Montana Kids (HMK) populations are both included in CPC+ as well.
Now available in 18 regions.
Cost savings were also found for the first 18 months of Iowa’s program. Estimates indicated that on average, $132 in Medicaid spending was saved in the first month of each beneficiary’s enrollment in the health home program. Estimated cost savings increased thereafter by about $11 per additional month of enrollment in the health home program. In the first 18 months of the program in Iowa, total savings of about $9.0 million were achieved, or nearly 20 percent of total projected Medicaid spending on health home enrollees.
Average hospital inpatient health costs for participants in the Health Homes study group decreased from CY 2013 to CY 2015, while costs for participants in the comparison group increased during this study period. Total inpatient costs for the study group decreased slightly from $10,884 in CY 2013 to $10,125 in CY 2015, while total inpatient costs for the comparison group increased from $10,741 in CY 2013 to $11,821 in CY 2015.
ED utilization rates were highest during a participant’s first six months of enrollment, with 37.6 percent of total participants visiting the ED at least one time during that enrollment span. The ED utilization rate declined the longer those participants stayed in the Health Home program. Participants who were in a Health Home program between 19 to 24 months had the lowest ED utilization rate at 27.5 percent of participants with at least one ED visit during that enrollment span.
Mathematica Policy Research (April 2016) independent evaluation prepared for CMS evaluating Year 2 of the program's implementation
CMS Blog (October 2015) results from first shared savings performance year (2014)
Mathematica Policy Research (January 2015) independent evaluation prepared for CMS
CMS Blog (October 2015) results from first shared savings performance year (2014)
CMS (November 2014) summary of practice reports from July 2014 for the second quarter of 2014, which spanned the period from April through June 2014
CMS Blog (October 2015) results from first shared savings performance year (2014)
Mathematica Policy Research (January 2015) independent evaluation prepared for CMS
Anthem Press Release (June 2015) Collective results from UC Davis, Sharp Rees-Stealy Medical Group, Sharp Community Medical Group, HealthCare Partners, Sante Community Physicians IPA and SeaView IPA over one year.
HealthCare Partners Press Release (June 2014)
HealthCare Partners Press Release (June 2014)
Results showed an increase of 22.9 per 1,000 PCP visits for high-risk patients.*
Anthem Press Release (June 2015) Collective results from UC Davis, Sharp Rees-Stealy Medical Group, Sharp Community Medical Group, HealthCare Partners, Sante Community Physicians IPA and SeaView IPA over one year.
HealthCare Partners Press Release (June 2014)
RTI independent evaluation (January 2016) evaluates first demonstration performance period, from July 2013 – December 2014
RTI independent evaluation (January 2016) evaluates first demonstration performance period, from July 2013 – December 2014
RTI independent evaluation (January 2016) evaluates first demonstration performance period, from July 2013 – December 2014
University of Minnesota Evaluation (February 2016) report evaluated the program from July 2010- December 2014
Minnesota Department of Health (January 2014):
HealthPartners Industry Report (2009):
University of Minnesota Evaluation (February 2016) report evaluated the program from July 2010- December 2014
Minnesota Department of Health (January 2014):
Minnesota Department of Health (January 2014):
University of Minnesota Evaluation (February 2016) report evaluated the program from July 2010- December 2014
University of Minnesota Evaluation (February 2016) report evaluated the program from July 2010- December 2014
HealthPartners Industry Report (2009):
Mathematica Evaluation (January 2015) Independent evaluation of first program year prepared for CMS
Among all patients and high-risk patients, there was only one favorable statistically significant impact and one unfavorable statistically significant impact on the claims-based quality-of-care process or outcome measures in Arkansas:
Mathematica Evaluation (January 2015) Independent evaluation of first program year prepared for CMS
BCBS Rhode Island Press Release (2015) evaluated more than 89,000 commercial and 14,000 Medicare Advantage members within BCBSRI’s PCMH over the 2009 – 2014 time period
BCBS Rhode Island Press Release (2015) evaluated more than 89,000 commercial and 14,000 Medicare Advantage members within BCBSRI’s PCMH over the 2009 – 2014 time period
BCBS Industry Report (2011)
Improved quality of care measures with a median rate of improvement of:
BCBS Rhode Island Press Release (2015) evaluated more than 89,000 commercial and 14,000 Medicare Advantage members within BCBSRI’s PCMH over the 2009 – 2014 time period
BCBS of Michigan Press Release (July 2015)
Health Affairs (April 2015) study included over 3.2 million people under age 65 enrolled for at least twelve continuous months during the study period (2008–2011)
Health Services Research (July 2013)
Health Affairs (April 2015) study included over 3.2 million people under age 65 enrolled for at least twelve continuous months during the study period (2008–2010 for quality measures)
Health Services Research (July 2013)
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (July 2014)
Health Affairs (April 2015) study included over 3.2 million people under age 65 enrolled for at least twelve continuous months during the study period (2008–2010 for quality measures)
Statistically significant improvement in 3 of 7 quality measures for preventive care (adolescent well care, adolescent immunization, and wellchild visits at ages 3–6)
JAMA Internal Medicine (February 2015) (Three-year study of 2,218 practices)
Health Services Research (July 2013)
Medical Care Research and Review (August 2015)
BCBS of Michigan Press Release (July 2015) based on 2015 claims data of patients who visit BCBSM PCMH-designated practices
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (July 2014)
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (July 2013)
Managed Healthcare Executive (December 2011)
Health Affairs (July 2015) evaluation of 49,000 program enrollees in Orange County from 2007-2010
Health Affairs (July 2015) evaluation of 49,000 program enrollees in Orange County from 2007-2010
JAMA Internal Medicine (November 2013)
CSI-RI 2013 Annual Report (May 2014)
practices collectively met every targeted patient heath outcome, including areas of weight management, diabetes, high blood pressure and tobacco cessation, and practices are showing improvement over time in all of the targeted areas
CTC-RI 2014 Annual Report (May 2015)
CSI-RI 2013 Annual Report (May 2014)
CSI-RI practices received increased, positive patient experience ratings, including access to care, communication with their care team, office staff responsiveness, shared decision making, and self-management support
CTC-RI 2014 Annual Report (May 2015)
CSI-RI 2013 Annual Report (May 2014)
More experienced CSI-RI practices saw reduced inpatient hospitalization, while the comparison group (primary care practices that are not CSI-RI patient-centered medical homes) experienced an increase
JAMA Internal Medicine (November 2013)
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2015) evaluation of the 4th year of the program. Service area includes Northern Virginia and DC
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2014)
CareFirst Industry Report (June 2013)
CareFirst Press Release (June 2013)
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2015) evaluation of the 4th year of the program. Service area includes Northern Virginia and DC
CareFirst Press Release (July 2014)
* results per 1000 CareFirst members
Cigna press release (May 2015)
Cigna press release (May 2015)
Cigna press release (May 2015)
Cigna press release (May 2015)
Cigna press release (May 2015)
ER use is 7 percent lower than market
Cigna press release (May 2015)
Cigna press release (May 2015)
Cigna press release (May 2015)
Mathematica Policy Research (April 2016) independent evaluation prepared for CMS evaluating Year 2 of the program's implementation
CMS Blog (October 2015) results from first shared savings performance year (2014)
Mathematica Policy Research (January 2015) independent evaluation prepared for CMS
CMS Blog (October 2015) results from first shared savings performance year (2014)
CMS (November 2014) summary of practice reports from July 2014 for the second quarter of 2014, which spanned the period from April through June 2014
CMS Blog (October 2015) results from first shared savings performance year (2014)
Mathematica Policy Research (January 2015) independent evaluation prepared for CMS
CMS Fact Sheet (August 2015) based on an evaluation of 2014 quality and financial performance results
JAMA (May 2015) study of 600,000 patients assistned to a Pioneer ACO in 2012 or 2013
Government Accountability Office (April 2015) report evaluated 23 ACOs that participated in the Pioneer Model in 2012 and 2013
CMS Fact Sheet (September 2014)
CMS Press Release (January 2014)
CMS Fact Sheet (August 2015) based on an evaluation of 2014 quality and financial performance results
Government Accountability Office (April 2015) report evaluated 23 ACOs that participated in the Pioneer Model in 2012 and 2013
CMS Fact Sheet (September 2014) (Results for second performance year)
JAMA (May 2015) study of 600,000 patients assistned to a Pioneer ACO in 2012 or 2013
Government Accountability Office (April 2015) report evaluated 23 ACOs that participated in the Pioneer Model in 2012 and 2013
CMS Fact Sheet (August 2015) based on an evaluation of 2014 quality and financial performance results
JAMA (May 2015) study of 600,000 patients assistned to a Pioneer ACO in 2012 or 2013
Government Accountability Office (April 2015) report evaluated 23 ACOs that participated in the Pioneer Model in 2012 and 2013
CMS Fact Sheet (September 2014) (Results for second performance year)
JAMA (May 2015) study of 600,000 patients assistned to a Pioneer ACO in 2012 or 2013
Mathematica Evaluation (January 2015) Independent evaluation of first program year prepared for CMS
Journal of General Internal Medicine (October 2015)
Two years after initiation of pilot, PCMH practices (vs. baseline) had:
Three years after initiation, PCMH practices showed sustained improvements with:
Health Affairs (September 2012)
Health Affairs (September 2012)
Journal of General Internal Medicine (October 2015)
Health Affairs (September 2012)
Journal of General Internal Medicine (October 2015)
Health Affairs (September 2012)
State Auditor Report (August 2015) based on data from July 1, 2003, through December 31, 2012
Population Health Management (September 2013) data review 2007-2011 for non-elderly Medicaid recipients with disabilities
North Carolina Medical Journal (January 2012)
Milliman Medicaid Cost Savings Report (Dec 2011)
State Auditor Report (August 2015) based on data from July 1, 2003, through December 31, 2012
Population Health Management (September 2013)
State Auditor Report (August 2015) based on data from July 1, 2003, through December 31, 2012
Population Health Management (September 2013)
Health Affairs (August 2013)
North Carolina Medical Journal (January 2012) evaluation of CCNC medical home enrollees vs. non-enrollees in 2010
Anthem Press Release (June 2015) Collective results from UC Davis, Sharp Rees-Stealy Medical Group, Sharp Community Medical Group, HealthCare Partners, Sante Community Physicians IPA and SeaView IPA over one year.
HealthCare Partners Press Release (June 2014)
HealthCare Partners Press Release (June 2014)
Results showed an increase of 22.9 per 1,000 PCP visits for high-risk patients.*
Anthem Press Release (June 2015) Collective results from UC Davis, Sharp Rees-Stealy Medical Group, Sharp Community Medical Group, HealthCare Partners, Sante Community Physicians IPA and SeaView IPA over one year.
HealthCare Partners Press Release (June 2014)
Health Affairs (April 2015) study of Medicare Advantage patients from 2006-2013
American Journal of Managed Care (March 2012) retrospective claims data analysis of 43 primary care clinics converted into PHN sites between 2006 and 2010
Population Health Management (June 2013) study compared 499 PHN patients with 359 non-PHN patients
Blue Shield of California (December 2015)
Health Affairs Blog (April 2014):
Blue Cross Blue Shield Industry Report (2012):
Health Affairs (September 2012):
Noteworthy examples include achieving 67% HbA1c testing mong diabetics, with 77% demonstrating control within clinically accepted standards. Additionally, sharpening our focus on women’s health, we set a target of achieving over 76% compliance in breast cancer screening among those due for a mammogram. We achieved 79% compliance.
Blue Shield of California (December 2015)
Blue Cross Blue Shield Industry Report (2012):
Health Affairs (September 2012):
Horizon Press Release (August 2015) evaluation of 750,000 patients participating in Horizon patient-centered practices
Horizon Industry Report (July 2014)
Horizon Industry Report (July 2013)
Horizon Press Release (August 2015) evaluation of 750,000 patients participating in Horizon patient-centered practices
Horizon Industry Report (July 2014)
Horizon Industry Report (July 2013)
Horizon Press Release (August 2015) evaluation of 750,000 patients participating in Horizon patient-centered practices
Horizon Industry Report (July 2014)
Horizon Industry Report (July 2013)
Horizon Press Release (August 2015) evaluation of 750,000 patients participating in Horizon patient-centered practices
Horizon Industry Report (July 2014)
Horizon Industry Report (July 2013)
Journal of Graduate Medical Education (June 2015)
Journal of Graduate Medical Education (June 2015)
Final Report (2018)
Uses NCQA accreditation.
Mathematica Evaluation (January 2015) Independent evaluation of first program year prepared for CMS
Among all patients in New York, there were several statistically significant improvements for the CPC group relative to the comparison group in the quality-of-care measures during the first year of CPC:
Similarly, among high-risk patients in New York, there were also many statistically significant improvements in quality-of-care measures for the CPC group relative to the comparison group, including:
Mathematica Evaluation (January 2015) Independent evaluation of first program year prepared for CMS
Among all patients in New York, there were two statistically significant impacts for the CPC group relative to the comparison group:
Among high-risk patients in New York, there were two statistically significant findings for the CPC group relative to the comparison group during Year 1:
Hartford Courant (July 2014)
Hartford Courant (July 2014)
Connecticut Department of Social Services Report (FY 2015)
Academic Pediatrics (May 2015) study sample includes 33,895 publicly insured children attributed to 32 practices
Minnesota Department of Human Services (June 2015)
Minnesota Department of Human Services (July 2014)
Strategies for success:
Medical Home Network (December 2014)
Medical Home Network (January 2015)
Medical Home Network (December 2014)
Medical Home Network (January 2015)
Medical Home Network (December 2014)
Tenet Health Press Release (August 2015)
RTI International (January 2015) independent evaluation prepared for CMS
The Brookings Institution, a nonprofit public policy organization based in Washington, DC, will evaluate the program’s impact on cost and quality.
Mathematica Policy Research (January 2015) Independent evaluation of first program year prepared for CMS
During the first year, statistically significant findings for the CPC group relative to the comparison group include:
Mathematica Policy Research (January 2015) Independent evaluation of first program year prepared for CMS
Among all patients in New Jersey, there were several favorable impacts on Medicare service use outcomes:
Mathematica Evaluation (January 2015) Independent evaluation of first program year prepared for CMS
Mathematica Policy Research (January 2015) Independent evaluation of first program year prepared for CMS
Mathematica Policy Research (January 2015) Independent evaluation of first program year prepared for CMS
Mathematica Policy Research (January 2015) Independent evaluation of first program year prepared for CMS
Oregon Health System Transformation 2014 Performance Report (June 2015) evaluation of CCOs on quality measures in 2014
Oregon Health System Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health Transformation Quarterly Report (November 2013)
Oregon Health System Transformation 2014 Performance Report (June 2015) evaluation of CCOs on quality measures in 2014
Oregon Health Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health Transformation Report (November 2013)
Oregon Health System Transformation 2014 Performance Report (June 2015) evaluation of CCOs on quality measures in 2014
Oregon Health System Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health System Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health System Transformation 2014 Performance Report (June 2015) evaluation of CCOs on quality measures in 2014
Oregon Health System Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health Transformation Quarterly Report (November 2013)
American Journal of Managed Care (February 2015)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2015)
JAMA (February 2014)
Pennsylvania Academy of Family Physicians (2012)
Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety (June 2011)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2015)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2015)
Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety (June 2011)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2015)
* (per 1000 patients per month vs. comparison)
American Journal of Managed Care (February 2015)
Qliance Press Release (January 2015)
Qliance Press Release (January 2015)
Qliance Press Release (January 2015) analysis examined insurance claims data from 2013 and 2014 for approximately 4,000 Qliance patients covered by employer benefit plans, and compared the cost of their care to that of non-Qliance patients who worked for the same employers.
practices that received global payments from RMHP for integrated care showed a 4.8 percent lower total cost of care for attributed patients, in a normalized comparison with a control group
Arkansas Department of Human Services (October 2015)
RTI International (January 2015)
Annals of Family Medicine (May 2013)
For the composite scores based on team-based care, 2 measures of productivity and cost were statistically significant:
Annals of Family Medicine (May 2013)
Annals of Family Medicine (May 2013)
Annals of Family Medicine (May 2013)
Journal of Healthcare Quality (January 2015) (retrospective study of 118 patients)
Population Health Management (September 2015)
Blueprint for Health Annual report (January 2015)
Blueprint for Health Annual Report (January 2014)
Total annual expenditures in 2012 were reduced by:
Blueprint for Health Annual Report (January 2014)
Blueprint for Health Annual Report (January 2014)
Increased preventive services:
Population Health Management (September 2015)
Population Health Management (July 2014)
inpatient days per 1000 members decreased by nearly 8%
Blueprint for Health Annual Report (January 2014)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
VA Health Services Research & Development (February 2019)In 2012, select Veterans Health Administration (VHA) facilities implemented a homeless-tailored medical home model, called Homeless Patient Aligned Care Teams (H-PACT), to improve care processes and outcomes for homeless Veterans.
American Journal of Managed Care (March 2015) During the study period from just prior to widespread PACT implementation to 2 years after PACT implementation began
Journal of Health Care Quality (November 2014) study evaluated PACT patients with post traumatic stress disorder using a pre/post study design
Health Affairs (June 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (July 2013)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (June 2015)
no statistically significant association between medical home implementation and improvements in 5 domains of patient care experiences
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (March 2015) During the study period from just prior to widespread PACT implementation to 2 years after PACT implementation began
Journal of Health Care Quality (November 2014) study evaluated PACT patients with post traumatic stress disorder using a pre/post study design
Health Services Research (August 2014)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
Health Affairs (June 2014)
Plos One (May 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (July 2013)
Health Affairs (June 2014)
The study found, "PACT was associated with modest increases in primary care visits and with modest decreases in both hospitalizations for ambulatory care–sensitive conditions and outpatient visits with mental health specialists. We found that these changes avoided $596 million in costs, compared to the investment in PACT of $774 million, for a potential net loss of $178 million in the study period. Although PACT has not generated a positive return, it is still maturing, and trends in costs and use are favorable. Adopting patient-centered care does not appear to have been a major financial risk for the VHA."
Wellmark Press Release (September 2015) based on a review of 2014 claims data
Wellmark Press Release (August 2014)
Wellmark Press Release (August 2014)
Wellmark Press Release (September 2015) based on a review of 2014 claims data
Wellmark Press Release (September 2015) based on a review of 2014 claims data
Wellmark Press Release (September 2015) based on a review of 2014 claims data
Wellmark Press Release (August 2014)
When compared to potential Health Homes members and health Homes cohorts, the cost savings are significant, despite the fact that total prescription costs increased due to the high cost of treating Hepatitis. For potential enrollees, total medical costs increased by $3.2 million from 2014 to 2015, which Health Homes enrollees only saw an increase of $0.2 million.
There was a 42% reduction in the average length of stay in a hospital for all Health Homes members who had Medicaid coverage in both 2014 and 2015. Members who were enrolled for the entire year saw a decrease of 32% from 2014. THe decrease can be attributed to better discharge planning.
WESTMED Medical Group outcomes (year 1):
WESTMED Medical Group outcomes (year 1):
HealthCare Partners outcomes (June 2014)
Health Leaders Media (June 2015)
By focusing on members who have two or more chronic conditions, an Anthem Blue Cross ACO in California has been able to save almost $8 million by reducing incidences of hospital stays and outpatient visits, and increasing the use of generic prescription drugs.
HealthCare Partners outcomes (June 2014)
Increase in quality measures:
HealthCare Partners outcomes (June 2014)
BCBS of Michigan Press Release (July 2015)
Health Affairs (April 2015) study included over 3.2 million people under age 65 enrolled for at least twelve continuous months during the study period (2008–2011)
Health Services Research (July 2013)
Health Affairs (April 2015) study included over 3.2 million people under age 65 enrolled for at least twelve continuous months during the study period (2008–2010 for quality measures)
Health Services Research (July 2013)
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (July 2014)
Health Affairs (April 2015) study included over 3.2 million people under age 65 enrolled for at least twelve continuous months during the study period (2008–2010 for quality measures)
Statistically significant improvement in 3 of 7 quality measures for preventive care (adolescent well care, adolescent immunization, and wellchild visits at ages 3–6)
JAMA Internal Medicine (February 2015) (Three-year study of 2,218 practices)
Health Services Research (July 2013)
Medical Care Research and Review (August 2015)
BCBS of Michigan Press Release (July 2015) based on 2015 claims data of patients who visit BCBSM PCMH-designated practices
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (July 2014)
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (July 2013)
Managed Healthcare Executive (December 2011)
JAMA Internal Medicine (November 2013)
CSI-RI 2013 Annual Report (May 2014)
practices collectively met every targeted patient heath outcome, including areas of weight management, diabetes, high blood pressure and tobacco cessation, and practices are showing improvement over time in all of the targeted areas
CTC-RI 2014 Annual Report (May 2015)
CSI-RI 2013 Annual Report (May 2014)
CSI-RI practices received increased, positive patient experience ratings, including access to care, communication with their care team, office staff responsiveness, shared decision making, and self-management support
CTC-RI 2014 Annual Report (May 2015)
CSI-RI 2013 Annual Report (May 2014)
More experienced CSI-RI practices saw reduced inpatient hospitalization, while the comparison group (primary care practices that are not CSI-RI patient-centered medical homes) experienced an increase
JAMA Internal Medicine (November 2013)
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2015) evaluation of the 4th year of the program. Service area includes Northern Virginia and DC
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2014)
CareFirst Press Release (June 2013)
CareFirst Press Release (June 2013)
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2015) evaluation of the 4th year of the program. Service area includes Northern Virginia and DC
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2014)
* results per 1000 CareFirst members
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2015) evaluation of the 4th year of the program. Service area includes Northern Virginia and DC
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2014)
CareFirst Industry Report (June 2013)
CareFirst Press Release (June 2013)
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2015) evaluation of the 4th year of the program. Service area includes Northern Virginia and DC
CareFirst Press Release (July 2014)
* results per 1000 CareFirst members
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2015) evaluation of the 4th year of the program. Service area includes Northern Virginia and DC
CareFirst Industry Report (June 2013)
CareFirst Industry Report (June 2013)
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2015) evaluation of the 4th year of the program. Service area includes Northern Virginia and DC
CareFirst Press Release (July 2014)
* results per 1000 CareFirst members
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2014)
* results per 1000 CareFirst members
Preventive Care and Screening: Influenza Immunization at 94.66 compared to ACO mean of 72.52
Preventive Care and Screening: Body Mass Index (BMI) Screening and Follow-Up at 93.55 compared to ACO mean of 70.69
Preventive Care and Screening: Tobacco Use: Screening and Cessation Intervention at 99.19 compared to ACO mean of 90.48
Mathematica Policy Research (April 2016) independent evaluation prepared for CMS evaluating Year 2 of the program's implementation
CMS Blog (October 2015) results from first shared savings performance year (2014)
Mathematica Policy Research (January 2015) independent evaluation prepared for CMS
CMS Blog (October 2015) results from first shared savings performance year (2014)
CMS (November 2014) summary of practice reports from July 2014 for the second quarter of 2014, which spanned the period from April through June 2014
CMS Blog (October 2015) results from first shared savings performance year (2014)
Mathematica Policy Research (January 2015) independent evaluation prepared for CMS
CMS Fact Sheet (August 2015) based on an evaluation of 2014 quality and financial performance results
JAMA (May 2015) study of 600,000 patients assistned to a Pioneer ACO in 2012 or 2013
Government Accountability Office (April 2015) report evaluated 23 ACOs that participated in the Pioneer Model in 2012 and 2013
CMS Fact Sheet (September 2014)
CMS Press Release (January 2014)
CMS Fact Sheet (August 2015) based on an evaluation of 2014 quality and financial performance results
Government Accountability Office (April 2015) report evaluated 23 ACOs that participated in the Pioneer Model in 2012 and 2013
CMS Fact Sheet (September 2014) (Results for second performance year)
JAMA (May 2015) study of 600,000 patients assistned to a Pioneer ACO in 2012 or 2013
Government Accountability Office (April 2015) report evaluated 23 ACOs that participated in the Pioneer Model in 2012 and 2013
CMS Fact Sheet (August 2015) based on an evaluation of 2014 quality and financial performance results
JAMA (May 2015) study of 600,000 patients assistned to a Pioneer ACO in 2012 or 2013
Government Accountability Office (April 2015) report evaluated 23 ACOs that participated in the Pioneer Model in 2012 and 2013
CMS Fact Sheet (September 2014) (Results for second performance year)
JAMA (May 2015) study of 600,000 patients assistned to a Pioneer ACO in 2012 or 2013
PCPCC 2018 Evidence Report
Reduced costs about $60 per member per month (PMPM) on adults and $20 PMPM on children as compared to eligible members who were not enrolled in an ACC over the same time period.
In dual eligible beneficiaries this cost savings was about $120 PMPM.
ACC 2014 Annual Report (November 2014)
The ACC program generated approximately $100 million in gross program savings ($31 million in net savings) in FY2013-2014
In FY2013-2014, approximately $14 million was reinvested into providers by the program (including incentive payments)
Colorado Legislative Report (November 2013)
$44 million gross, $6 million net reduction in total cost of care (cost avoidance) for clients enrolled in the ACC Program
Colorado Legislative Report (November 2013)
Colorado Legislative Report (November 2013)
ACC 2014 Annual Report (November 2014)
Colorado Legislative Report (November 2013) outcomes relative to a comparison population prior to program implementation:
Anthem Press Release (June 2015) Collective results from UC Davis, Sharp Rees-Stealy Medical Group, Sharp Community Medical Group, HealthCare Partners, Sante Community Physicians IPA and SeaView IPA over one year.
HealthCare Partners Press Release (June 2014)
HealthCare Partners Press Release (June 2014)
Results showed an increase of 22.9 per 1,000 PCP visits for high-risk patients.*
Anthem Press Release (June 2015) Collective results from UC Davis, Sharp Rees-Stealy Medical Group, Sharp Community Medical Group, HealthCare Partners, Sante Community Physicians IPA and SeaView IPA over one year.
HealthCare Partners Press Release (June 2014)
Health Services Research (June 2014)
Department of Health Services Research (March 2011)
Improvements in the quality of care for patients with chronic conditions:
In a comparison of data for 2012 (the first year of Hennepin Health) and 2013:
Blue Shield of California (December 2015)
Health Affairs Blog (April 2014):
Blue Cross Blue Shield Industry Report (2012):
Health Affairs (September 2012):
Noteworthy examples include achieving 67% HbA1c testing mong diabetics, with 77% demonstrating control within clinically accepted standards. Additionally, sharpening our focus on women’s health, we set a target of achieving over 76% compliance in breast cancer screening among those due for a mammogram. We achieved 79% compliance.
Blue Shield of California (December 2015)
Blue Cross Blue Shield Industry Report (2012):
Health Affairs (September 2012):
Horizon Press Release (August 2015) evaluation of 750,000 patients participating in Horizon patient-centered practices
Horizon Industry Report (July 2014)
Horizon Industry Report (July 2013)
Horizon Press Release (August 2015) evaluation of 750,000 patients participating in Horizon patient-centered practices
Horizon Industry Report (July 2014)
Horizon Industry Report (July 2013)
Horizon Press Release (August 2015) evaluation of 750,000 patients participating in Horizon patient-centered practices
Horizon Industry Report (July 2014)
Horizon Industry Report (July 2013)
Horizon Press Release (August 2015) evaluation of 750,000 patients participating in Horizon patient-centered practices
Horizon Industry Report (July 2014)
Horizon Industry Report (July 2013)
Hartford Courant (July 2014)
Hartford Courant (July 2014)
Connecticut Department of Social Services Report (FY 2015)
Most prevention measures show substantial improvements, particularly those with low levels of compliance in 2007 (early in the PCMH intervention)
2012 physician satisfaction survey results:
American Journal of Managed Care Evaluation (March 2014):
IBC Press Release (July 2013):
BlueCross BlueShield Industry Report (2008-2011)
Better diabetes care:
Health Services Research (August 2014):
American Journal of Managed Care Evaluation (March 2014):
American Journal of Managed Care Evaluation (March 2014):
Minnesota Department of Human Services (June 2015)
Minnesota Department of Human Services (July 2014)
Strategies for success:
For the 2016 performance year, CCPM achieved $4.3 million in total savings for Medicare, with $2.1 million in shared savings returning to CCPM and its member organizations – all of which are federally qualified health centers or critical access and community hospitals who are collectively committed to improving the quality and effectiveness of health care delivery and reducing unnecessary healthcare costs.
In the areas of preventive care and the treatment of at-risk populations with chronic disease, CCPM performed better than the mean performance rate of all participating MSSP ACOs for 14 out of 17 metrics.
CCPM performed well in patient/caregiver experience, which is assessed through random surveys of Medicare members for the 2016 performance year.
Improved diabetes management:
Maryland Health Care Commission (December 2013)
Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved (February 2014)
Maryland Health Care Commission (December 2013)
Maryland Health Care Commission (December 2013)
Patient Satisfaction
Provider Satisfaction
Maryland Health Care Commission (December 2013)
Medical Home Network (December 2014)
Medical Home Network (January 2015)
Medical Home Network (December 2014)
Medical Home Network (January 2015)
Medical Home Network (December 2014)
In 2012, previously undiagnosed conditions were diagnosed and preventative screening rates increased dramatically due to a 95% participation rate in the annual physical
University of Minnesota Evaluation (February 2016) report evaluated the program from July 2010- December 2014
Minnesota Department of Health (January 2014):
HealthPartners Industry Report (2009):
University of Minnesota Evaluation (February 2016) report evaluated the program from July 2010- December 2014
Minnesota Department of Health (January 2014):
Minnesota Department of Health (January 2014):
University of Minnesota Evaluation (February 2016) report evaluated the program from July 2010- December 2014
University of Minnesota Evaluation (February 2016) report evaluated the program from July 2010- December 2014
HealthPartners Industry Report (2009):
Montefiore’s ACO made great strides in improving quality performance in key areas like depression screening and screening for risk of future falls.
Compared to the year before implementation of the network:
Oregon Health System Transformation 2014 Performance Report (June 2015) evaluation of CCOs on quality measures in 2014
Oregon Health System Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health Transformation Quarterly Report (November 2013)
Oregon Health System Transformation 2014 Performance Report (June 2015) evaluation of CCOs on quality measures in 2014
Oregon Health Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health Transformation Report (November 2013)
Oregon Health System Transformation 2014 Performance Report (June 2015) evaluation of CCOs on quality measures in 2014
Oregon Health System Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health System Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health System Transformation 2014 Performance Report (June 2015) evaluation of CCOs on quality measures in 2014
Oregon Health System Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health Transformation Quarterly Report (November 2013)
American Journal of Managed Care (February 2015)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2015)
JAMA (February 2014)
Pennsylvania Academy of Family Physicians (2012)
Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety (June 2011)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2015)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2015)
Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety (June 2011)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2015)
* (per 1000 patients per month vs. comparison)
American Journal of Managed Care (February 2015)
2018
2014
Journal of Ambulatory Care Management (Jan-March 2013)
Population Health Management (September 2015)
Blueprint for Health Annual report (January 2015)
Blueprint for Health Annual Report (January 2014)
Total annual expenditures in 2012 were reduced by:
Blueprint for Health Annual Report (January 2014)
Blueprint for Health Annual Report (January 2014)
Increased preventive services:
Population Health Management (September 2015)
Population Health Management (July 2014)
inpatient days per 1000 members decreased by nearly 8%
Blueprint for Health Annual Report (January 2014)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
VA Health Services Research & Development (February 2019)In 2012, select Veterans Health Administration (VHA) facilities implemented a homeless-tailored medical home model, called Homeless Patient Aligned Care Teams (H-PACT), to improve care processes and outcomes for homeless Veterans.
American Journal of Managed Care (March 2015) During the study period from just prior to widespread PACT implementation to 2 years after PACT implementation began
Journal of Health Care Quality (November 2014) study evaluated PACT patients with post traumatic stress disorder using a pre/post study design
Health Affairs (June 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (July 2013)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (June 2015)
no statistically significant association between medical home implementation and improvements in 5 domains of patient care experiences
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (March 2015) During the study period from just prior to widespread PACT implementation to 2 years after PACT implementation began
Journal of Health Care Quality (November 2014) study evaluated PACT patients with post traumatic stress disorder using a pre/post study design
Health Services Research (August 2014)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
Health Affairs (June 2014)
Plos One (May 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (July 2013)
Health Affairs (June 2014)
The study found, "PACT was associated with modest increases in primary care visits and with modest decreases in both hospitalizations for ambulatory care–sensitive conditions and outpatient visits with mental health specialists. We found that these changes avoided $596 million in costs, compared to the investment in PACT of $774 million, for a potential net loss of $178 million in the study period. Although PACT has not generated a positive return, it is still maturing, and trends in costs and use are favorable. Adopting patient-centered care does not appear to have been a major financial risk for the VHA."
Wellmark Press Release (September 2015) based on a review of 2014 claims data
Wellmark Press Release (August 2014)
Wellmark Press Release (August 2014)
Wellmark Press Release (September 2015) based on a review of 2014 claims data
Wellmark Press Release (September 2015) based on a review of 2014 claims data
Wellmark Press Release (September 2015) based on a review of 2014 claims data
Wellmark Press Release (August 2014)
Increase in preventive services for asthmatics
In the 1st year of operation, the Pioneer ACO:
BCBS of Michigan Press Release (July 2015)
Health Affairs (April 2015) study included over 3.2 million people under age 65 enrolled for at least twelve continuous months during the study period (2008–2011)
Health Services Research (July 2013)
Health Affairs (April 2015) study included over 3.2 million people under age 65 enrolled for at least twelve continuous months during the study period (2008–2010 for quality measures)
Health Services Research (July 2013)
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (July 2014)
Health Affairs (April 2015) study included over 3.2 million people under age 65 enrolled for at least twelve continuous months during the study period (2008–2010 for quality measures)
Statistically significant improvement in 3 of 7 quality measures for preventive care (adolescent well care, adolescent immunization, and wellchild visits at ages 3–6)
JAMA Internal Medicine (February 2015) (Three-year study of 2,218 practices)
Health Services Research (July 2013)
Medical Care Research and Review (August 2015)
BCBS of Michigan Press Release (July 2015) based on 2015 claims data of patients who visit BCBSM PCMH-designated practices
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (July 2014)
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (July 2013)
Managed Healthcare Executive (December 2011)
JAMA Internal Medicine (November 2013)
CSI-RI 2013 Annual Report (May 2014)
practices collectively met every targeted patient heath outcome, including areas of weight management, diabetes, high blood pressure and tobacco cessation, and practices are showing improvement over time in all of the targeted areas
CTC-RI 2014 Annual Report (May 2015)
CSI-RI 2013 Annual Report (May 2014)
CSI-RI practices received increased, positive patient experience ratings, including access to care, communication with their care team, office staff responsiveness, shared decision making, and self-management support
CTC-RI 2014 Annual Report (May 2015)
CSI-RI 2013 Annual Report (May 2014)
More experienced CSI-RI practices saw reduced inpatient hospitalization, while the comparison group (primary care practices that are not CSI-RI patient-centered medical homes) experienced an increase
JAMA Internal Medicine (November 2013)
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2015) evaluation of the 4th year of the program. Service area includes Northern Virginia and DC
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2014)
CareFirst Press Release (June 2013)
CareFirst Press Release (June 2013)
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2015) evaluation of the 4th year of the program. Service area includes Northern Virginia and DC
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2014)
* results per 1000 CareFirst members
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2015) evaluation of the 4th year of the program. Service area includes Northern Virginia and DC
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2014)
CareFirst Industry Report (June 2013)
CareFirst Press Release (June 2013)
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2015) evaluation of the 4th year of the program. Service area includes Northern Virginia and DC
CareFirst Press Release (July 2014)
* results per 1000 CareFirst members
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2015) evaluation of the 4th year of the program. Service area includes Northern Virginia and DC
CareFirst Industry Report (June 2013)
CareFirst Industry Report (June 2013)
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2015) evaluation of the 4th year of the program. Service area includes Northern Virginia and DC
CareFirst Press Release (July 2014)
* results per 1000 CareFirst members
CareFirst Industry Report (July 2014)
* results per 1000 CareFirst members
PCPCC 2018 Evidence Report
Reduced costs about $60 per member per month (PMPM) on adults and $20 PMPM on children as compared to eligible members who were not enrolled in an ACC over the same time period.
In dual eligible beneficiaries this cost savings was about $120 PMPM.
ACC 2014 Annual Report (November 2014)
The ACC program generated approximately $100 million in gross program savings ($31 million in net savings) in FY2013-2014
In FY2013-2014, approximately $14 million was reinvested into providers by the program (including incentive payments)
Colorado Legislative Report (November 2013)
$44 million gross, $6 million net reduction in total cost of care (cost avoidance) for clients enrolled in the ACC Program
Colorado Legislative Report (November 2013)
Colorado Legislative Report (November 2013)
ACC 2014 Annual Report (November 2014)
Colorado Legislative Report (November 2013) outcomes relative to a comparison population prior to program implementation:
State Auditor Report (August 2015) based on data from July 1, 2003, through December 31, 2012
Population Health Management (September 2013) data review 2007-2011 for non-elderly Medicaid recipients with disabilities
North Carolina Medical Journal (January 2012)
Milliman Medicaid Cost Savings Report (Dec 2011)
State Auditor Report (August 2015) based on data from July 1, 2003, through December 31, 2012
Population Health Management (September 2013)
State Auditor Report (August 2015) based on data from July 1, 2003, through December 31, 2012
Population Health Management (September 2013)
Health Affairs (August 2013)
North Carolina Medical Journal (January 2012) evaluation of CCNC medical home enrollees vs. non-enrollees in 2010
Intervention physicians significantly improved two of 11 quality indicators:
3.8 fewer ED visits per year, saving approximately $1,900 in ED costs per physician, per year.
Health Affairs (April 2015) study of Medicare Advantage patients from 2006-2013
American Journal of Managed Care (March 2012) retrospective claims data analysis of 43 primary care clinics converted into PHN sites between 2006 and 2010
Population Health Management (June 2013) study compared 499 PHN patients with 359 non-PHN patients
Health Affairs (May 2010)
Annals of Family Medicine (May 2013)
Health Affairs (May 2010)
American Journal of Managed Care (September 2009)
Annals of Family Medicine (May 2013)
Horizon Press Release (August 2015) evaluation of 750,000 patients participating in Horizon patient-centered practices
Horizon Industry Report (July 2014)
Horizon Industry Report (July 2013)
Horizon Press Release (August 2015) evaluation of 750,000 patients participating in Horizon patient-centered practices
Horizon Industry Report (July 2014)
Horizon Industry Report (July 2013)
Horizon Press Release (August 2015) evaluation of 750,000 patients participating in Horizon patient-centered practices
Horizon Industry Report (July 2014)
Horizon Industry Report (July 2013)
Horizon Press Release (August 2015) evaluation of 750,000 patients participating in Horizon patient-centered practices
Horizon Industry Report (July 2014)
Horizon Industry Report (July 2013)
American Journal of Managed Care Evaluation (March 2014):
IBC Press Release (July 2013):
BlueCross BlueShield Industry Report (2008-2011)
Better diabetes care:
Health Services Research (August 2014):
American Journal of Managed Care Evaluation (March 2014):
American Journal of Managed Care Evaluation (March 2014):
Maryland Health Care Commission (December 2013)
Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved (February 2014)
Maryland Health Care Commission (December 2013)
Maryland Health Care Commission (December 2013)
Patient Satisfaction
Provider Satisfaction
Maryland Health Care Commission (December 2013)
Department of Mental Health and MO HealthNet (November 2013) report summarizes the clinical outcomes and system impact achieved during the first 18 months of the program
Department of Mental Health and MO HealthNet (November 2013) report summarizes the clinical outcomes and system impact achieved during the first 18 months of the program
Department of Mental Health and MO HealthNet (November 2013) report summarizes the clinical outcomes and system impact achieved during the first 18 months of the program
Oregon Health System Transformation 2014 Performance Report (June 2015) evaluation of CCOs on quality measures in 2014
Oregon Health System Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health Transformation Quarterly Report (November 2013)
Oregon Health System Transformation 2014 Performance Report (June 2015) evaluation of CCOs on quality measures in 2014
Oregon Health Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health Transformation Report (November 2013)
Oregon Health System Transformation 2014 Performance Report (June 2015) evaluation of CCOs on quality measures in 2014
Oregon Health System Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health System Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health System Transformation 2014 Performance Report (June 2015) evaluation of CCOs on quality measures in 2014
Oregon Health System Transformation 2013 Performance Report (June 2014)
Oregon Health Transformation Quarterly Report (November 2013)
During the first year of the initiative:
Hospitals that participated in the Quality Blue readmissions portion of the program for four consecutive years showed a decrease of nearly three percent for 7-day inpatient readmissions. Those same hospitals also showed a nearly five percent decrease in 30-day readmissions.
As of December 2014:
Journal of Ambulatory Care Management (Jan-March 2013)
Annals of Family Medicine (May 2013)
For the composite scores based on team-based care, 2 measures of productivity and cost were statistically significant:
Annals of Family Medicine (May 2013)
Annals of Family Medicine (May 2013)
Annals of Family Medicine (May 2013)
Journal of Healthcare Quality (January 2015) (retrospective study of 118 patients)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
VA Health Services Research & Development (February 2019)In 2012, select Veterans Health Administration (VHA) facilities implemented a homeless-tailored medical home model, called Homeless Patient Aligned Care Teams (H-PACT), to improve care processes and outcomes for homeless Veterans.
American Journal of Managed Care (March 2015) During the study period from just prior to widespread PACT implementation to 2 years after PACT implementation began
Journal of Health Care Quality (November 2014) study evaluated PACT patients with post traumatic stress disorder using a pre/post study design
Health Affairs (June 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (July 2013)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (June 2015)
no statistically significant association between medical home implementation and improvements in 5 domains of patient care experiences
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (March 2015) During the study period from just prior to widespread PACT implementation to 2 years after PACT implementation began
Journal of Health Care Quality (November 2014) study evaluated PACT patients with post traumatic stress disorder using a pre/post study design
Health Services Research (August 2014)
JAMA Internal Medicine (June 2014)
Health Affairs (June 2014)
Plos One (May 2014)
American Journal of Managed Care (July 2013)
Health Affairs (June 2014)
The study found, "PACT was associated with modest increases in primary care visits and with modest decreases in both hospitalizations for ambulatory care–sensitive conditions and outpatient visits with mental health specialists. We found that these changes avoided $596 million in costs, compared to the investment in PACT of $774 million, for a potential net loss of $178 million in the study period. Although PACT has not generated a positive return, it is still maturing, and trends in costs and use are favorable. Adopting patient-centered care does not appear to have been a major financial risk for the VHA."
New England Journal of Medicine (October 2014)
Health Affairs (August 2012)
In 2010, provider groups that joined the AQC in 2009 continued to improve quality and outcomes—while groups that joined in 2010 made significant quality improvements in their first year. Participating groups exhibited exceptionally high performance for all clinical outcome measures, with many approaching performance levels believed to be the best achievable for chronic conditions, such as diabetes, heart disease, and hypertension.
AQC improved health outcomes to 12 percent above the HEDIS national average
When the program expanded to include patients with coronary artery disease, cost savings from fewer emergency room visits and unplanned admissions increased from $500 to $1,200 per patient per year from 2005 to 2007
Diabetic patients experienced a:
Coronary artery disease patients experienced a:
Quality of care scores for cardiovascular disease care measures have steadily improved from 14.7% in 2009 to 27.9% in 2012. During the same time period, the proportion of adults with their blood pressure controlled improved from 63% to 67.4%.
More than 76% of BCBSND patients are assigned to a patient-centered
medical home.
Average total cost increased in both the QBPC and control groups in 2014, but the increase was significantly less in the intervention group—a difference of $27.09 per member per month (PMPM) (P ≤.001). Savings in total cost were derived largely from a decrease in hospitalizations—a difference of $18.85 PMPM (P = .0023).
Savings were associated with shifts in healthcare utilization by the intervention group toward proactive management, including increased primary care physician visits (P = .0106) and higher screening rates for diabetes (P = .0019).
Compared with expected costs, Dartmouth-Hitchcock achieved performance improvements in per patient, per month costs of $1.78
Journal of General Internal Medicine (October 2015)
Two years after initiation of pilot, PCMH practices (vs. baseline) had:
Three years after initiation, PCMH practices showed sustained improvements with:
Health Affairs (September 2012)
Health Affairs (September 2012)
Journal of General Internal Medicine (October 2015)
Health Affairs (September 2012)
Journal of General Internal Medicine (October 2015)
Health Affairs (September 2012)
5.1% PaMPM decrease in outpatient surgery costs*
Results showed an increase of 22.9 per 1,000 PCP visits for high-risk patients.*
7.8% fewer inpatient admissions per 1000*
5.7% fewer inpatient days per 1000*
7.4% decrease in acute admissions for high-risk patients with chronic conditions*
3.5% decrease in ER costs and 1.6% reduction in ER utilization*
Health Affairs (April 2015) study of Medicare Advantage patients from 2006-2013
American Journal of Managed Care (March 2012) retrospective claims data analysis of 43 primary care clinics converted into PHN sites between 2006 and 2010
Population Health Management (June 2013) study compared 499 PHN patients with 359 non-PHN patients
Blue Shield of California (December 2015)
Health Affairs Blog (April 2014):
Blue Cross Blue Shield Industry Report (2012):
Health Affairs (September 2012):
Noteworthy examples include achieving 67% HbA1c testing mong diabetics, with 77% demonstrating control within clinically accepted standards. Additionally, sharpening our focus on women’s health, we set a target of achieving over 76% compliance in breast cancer screening among those due for a mammogram. We achieved 79% compliance.
Blue Shield of California (December 2015)
Blue Cross Blue Shield Industry Report (2012):
Health Affairs (September 2012):
United States Air Force (May 2011)
United States Air Force (May 2011)
American Academy of Family Physicians (February 2012)
The total cost reduction for sites participating in the PCMH program initially lagged behind improvements in service use and clinical quality. However, within the first year, overall medical costs were contained, while decreases in pharmacy costs were accelerated. This led to a significant reduction in total costs by the end of the second year.
From 2008-2010:
Changes in Hospital Service Use (per 1,000 members)
BCBS Rhode Island Press Release (2015) evaluated more than 89,000 commercial and 14,000 Medicare Advantage members within BCBSRI’s PCMH over the 2009 – 2014 time period
BCBS Rhode Island Press Release (2015) evaluated more than 89,000 commercial and 14,000 Medicare Advantage members within BCBSRI’s PCMH over the 2009 – 2014 time period
BCBS Industry Report (2011)
Improved quality of care measures with a median rate of improvement of:
BCBS Rhode Island Press Release (2015) evaluated more than 89,000 commercial and 14,000 Medicare Advantage members within BCBSRI’s PCMH over the 2009 – 2014 time period
"BCBST found that members enrolled in a PCMH had less emergency room utilization and lower inpatient admissions compared with non-PCMH members. For example, asthma and diabetes ER utilization, as well as asthma and diabetes hospital admissions, were lower in the PCMH group than the non-PCMH group."
New England Journal of Medicine (October 2014)
Health Affairs (August 2012)
In 2010, provider groups that joined the AQC in 2009 continued to improve quality and outcomes—while groups that joined in 2010 made significant quality improvements in their first year. Participating groups exhibited exceptionally high performance for all clinical outcome measures, with many approaching performance levels believed to be the best achievable for chronic conditions, such as diabetes, heart disease, and hypertension.
AQC improved health outcomes to 12 percent above the HEDIS national average
BCBS of Michigan Press Release (July 2015)
Health Affairs (April 2015) study included over 3.2 million people under age 65 enrolled for at least twelve continuous months during the study period (2008–2011)
Health Services Research (July 2013)
Health Affairs (April 2015) study included over 3.2 million people under age 65 enrolled for at least twelve continuous months during the study period (2008–2010 for quality measures)
Health Services Research (July 2013)
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (July 2014)
Health Affairs (April 2015) study included over 3.2 million people under age 65 enrolled for at least twelve continuous months during the study period (2008–2010 for quality measures)
Statistically significant improvement in 3 of 7 quality measures for preventive care (adolescent well care, adolescent immunization, and wellchild visits at ages 3–6)
JAMA Internal Medicine (February 2015) (Three-year study of 2,218 practices)
Health Services Research (July 2013)
Medical Care Research and Review (August 2015)
BCBS of Michigan Press Release (July 2015) based on 2015 claims data of patients who visit BCBSM PCMH-designated practices
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (July 2014)
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan (July 2013)
Managed Healthcare Executive (December 2011)
State Auditor Report (August 2015) based on data from July 1, 2003, through December 31, 2012
Population Health Management (September 2013) data review 2007-2011 for non-elderly Medicaid recipients with disabilities
North Carolina Medical Journal (January 2012)
Milliman Medicaid Cost Savings Report (Dec 2011)
State Auditor Report (August 2015) based on data from July 1, 2003, through December 31, 2012
Population Health Management (September 2013)
State Auditor Report (August 2015) based on data from July 1, 2003, through December 31, 2012
Population Health Management (September 2013)
Health Affairs (August 2013)
North Carolina Medical Journal (January 2012) evaluation of CCNC medical home enrollees vs. non-enrollees in 2010
Health Services Research (June 2014)
Department of Health Services Research (March 2011)
Journal of Ambulatory Care Management (January 2011)
HealthPartners industry report (2009)
HealthPartners industry report (2009)
HealthPartners industry report (2009)
HealthPartners industry report (2009)
HealthPartners industry report (2009)
United States Air Force (May 2011)
United States Air Force (May 2011)
American Academy of Family Physicians (February 2012)
Health Affairs (May 2010)
Annals of Family Medicine (May 2013)
Health Affairs (May 2010)
American Journal of Managed Care (September 2009)
Annals of Family Medicine (May 2013)
reduced health care costs of pilot participants 20% versus control group
Health Affairs (May 2010)
Annals of Family Medicine (May 2013)
Health Affairs (May 2010)
American Journal of Managed Care (September 2009)
Annals of Family Medicine (May 2013)
Journal of Ambulatory Care Management (January 2011)
HealthPartners industry report (2009)
HealthPartners industry report (2009)
HealthPartners industry report (2009)
HealthPartners industry report (2009)
HealthPartners industry report (2009)
University of Minnesota Evaluation (February 2016) report evaluated the program from July 2010- December 2014
Minnesota Department of Health (January 2014):
HealthPartners Industry Report (2009):
University of Minnesota Evaluation (February 2016) report evaluated the program from July 2010- December 2014
Minnesota Department of Health (January 2014):
Minnesota Department of Health (January 2014):
University of Minnesota Evaluation (February 2016) report evaluated the program from July 2010- December 2014
University of Minnesota Evaluation (February 2016) report evaluated the program from July 2010- December 2014
HealthPartners Industry Report (2009):